Guanaco logo
Guanacos eat gluten-free
CleanPlate
Rankings/Carnegie Hill

CleanPlate · New York

Best Gluten-Free Restaurants in Carnegie Hill, New York

Looking for gluten-free restaurants in Carnegie Hill? CleanPlate rates 20 restaurants in Carnegie Hill based on GF safety signals including cross-contamination risk, dedicated fryers, menu labeling, and real diner experiences.

20 Restaurants — Ranked by GF Safety
01
Toloache

Mexican

Extensive gluten-free options with clear menu labeling, knowledgeable staff, and repeated positive celiac experiences; dedicated fryer reported for chips and strong diner confidence.

99
02
Noglu

French

Dedicated gluten-free bakery and cafe with a wide variety of pastries, breads, and savory options, consistently praised for safety and selection by celiac diners. High prices are the most common caveat.

98
03
Le Botaniste

Mediterranean

Nearly the entire menu is gluten-free and clearly labeled, with consistently positive reviews from gluten-free diners.

95
04
Orsay

French

Menu features several marked gluten-free options and staff are generally knowledgeable, with recent reviews noting a positive and flexible experience.

92
05
Bondi Sushi

Japanese

Staff are knowledgeable about gluten-free needs, with menu items marked and positive experiences reported by celiac diners; protocols are attentive but can be less consistent during busy times.

90
06
Lilli and Loo

Chinese

Extensive gluten-free menu with clear labeling, many dedicated options, and consistently excellent reviews from gluten-free diners.

89
07
Yasouvlaki

Greek

Menu items are marked gluten-free and several dishes can be made gluten-free, but protocols and cross-contact handling are not well documented.

88
08
Dig Inn

American

Clear menu labeling and many naturally gluten-free bowls make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners, with staff generally knowledgeable about ingredients.

88
09
fresh&co

American

Clear gluten-free labeling and a wide variety of marked options make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners, with staff generally knowledgeable about celiac needs. No evidence of above-baseline cross-contamination risk, but protocols for strict avoidance are not fully documented.

88
10
Island

New American

Menu items are clearly marked gluten-free and recent celiac diners report feeling safe, with several salads, mains, and sides adaptable for gluten-free needs. Protocols for cross-contact are not fully detailed, so handling is not well documented.

87
11
Thai At Lex

Thai

Clear gluten-free labeling and consistently positive reviews for pad thai and curries make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners; options are somewhat limited beyond these staples.

87
12
Thai Hot Box

Thai

Clear gluten-free labeling on the menu and several well-liked GF options make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners; staff are reported as knowledgeable, though kitchen protocols are not fully detailed.

84
13
Sushi Goda

Japanese

Menu includes gluten-free labels and gluten-free soy sauce is available, but protocols and handling are not well documented.

82
14
Come Prima

Italian

Gluten-free pasta is available and noted on the menu, with several positive diner experiences highlighting successful gluten-free meals.

81
15
Pascalou

French

Several gluten-free-friendly dishes are available and some are labeled, but protocols and staff knowledge are not well documented.

79
16
Eli's Night Shift

American

Gluten-free pizza available with clear menu labeling and several adaptable options, though kitchen protocols for cross-contact are not fully detailed.

79
17
Hoexter's

New American

Staff is generally knowledgeable and many menu items can be made gluten-free, but recent diner reports highlight inconsistent safety and a significant cross-contamination incident.

77
18
Serafina Fabulous Pizza 79th (UES)

Italian

Several gluten-free pasta and entrée options with helpful staff and positive recent gluten-free experiences; protocols are not fully documented for celiac-level safety.

77
19
Bar Italia

Italian

Bar Italia offers many gluten-free options, including pizza and pasta, with staff frequently described as knowledgeable and flexible; some celiac diners report positive experiences, though isolated incidents of cross-contact have occurred.

77
20
Tokugawa Sushi Restaurant

Japanese

Clear gluten-free labeling on the menu and several labeled GF sushi, sashimi, and appetizer options make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners; protocols for handling and substitutions are not fully detailed.

76