Menu items are clearly marked gluten-free and at least one recent celiac diner felt safe eating here, though the facility is not dedicated gluten-free.
Highlights
Some gluten-free dishes to choose from.
No GF-related illness reports found in recent data.
Consistently positive feedback from gluten-free diners.
Did this help you decide?
Island, located at 1305 Madison Ave, is a neighborhood staple known for its seafood and American-style meats and pastas, all served in a yacht-club style setting. It's a go-to spot for locals looking for a reliable meal, whether it's a casual dinner or a weekend brunch. The restaurant doesn't highlight a specific chef or owner with a notable background, focusing instead on its consistent offerings and welcoming vibe.
Moderate confidence — some signals are inferred. Confirm details directly with the restaurant.
CleanPlate Weekly
The safest gluten-free spots in NYC — a few hand-picked places in your inbox each week.
