Guanaco logo
Guanacos eat gluten-free
CleanPlate
Rankings/Midtown/GF Pizza

CleanPlate · New York

Best GF Pizza Spots in Midtown, New York

Looking for gluten-free gf pizza in Midtown? CleanPlate rates 6 spots in Midtown based on GF safety signals including cross-contamination risk, dedicated fryers, menu labeling, and real diner experiences.

6 Restaurants — Ranked by GF Safety
01
Nino's 46

Italian

Extensive gluten-free menu with clear labeling, knowledgeable staff, and many positive celiac experiences; dedicated fryer and pasta pot available, but pizza is cooked in a shared oven which has caused rare issues for highly sensitive diners.

89
02
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store

American / Gastropub

Clear gluten-free labeling on the menu and several viable options, including salads, entrees, and a cauliflower pizza crust, with recent reviews noting attentive staff and menu flexibility. Fries are not gluten-free due to a shared fryer.

86
03
257 7 ave Ciao Bella restauran pizzeria

Italian, Pizza

Ciao Bella offers a wide range of gluten-free pizzas with clear menu labeling and positive feedback on safe handling, including use of a separate pan and slicer for gluten-free orders. Protocols for other menu items are not well documented.

84
04
Made in New York Pizza

Pizza

Gluten-free personal pies are available and staff use separate trays and provide a dedicated pizza cutter, with recent reviews noting careful handling and generally positive experiences. Crust quality is mixed, but cross-contact protocols are above average for NYC pizza.

84
05
Rosemary's Midtown

Italian

Several menu items can be made gluten-free, including pizza and pasta, but all gluten-free options carry a cross-contamination warning and protocols are not fully documented.

76
06
Connolly's

Irish Pub

Several menu items are marked gluten-free and staff are generally knowledgeable, but lack of a dedicated fryer and some recent reports of gluten exposure require caution for sensitive diners.

75