No evidence of gluten-free protocols or menu labeling; gluten-free experience is not documented.
Gluten-free options not yet assessed.
No GF-related illness reports found in recent data.
Not enough recent gluten-free reviews yet.
Did this help you decide?
Peter McManus Cafe is a classic New York Irish pub, known for its Pop Pop’s Top Shelf Burger, which has won the Battle of the Burger multiple times. It's a neighborhood staple, perfect for grabbing a pint and a burger with friends. The cafe has been family-run since 1936, currently operated by fourth-generation owner Justin McManus. It's a genuine spot with a rich history, even featuring in movies and TV shows like "Highlander" and "The Other Guys".
Limited data — scores are based on partial information and may not fully reflect this restaurant's practices.
CleanPlate Weekly
The safest gluten-free spots in NYC — a few hand-picked places in your inbox each week.
