Some gluten-free options are available and noted by diners, but menu labeling and kitchen protocols are not well documented.
Highlights
A limited gluten-free selection.
No GF-related illness reports found in recent data.
Consistently positive feedback from gluten-free diners.
Did this help you decide?
Edgar's Cafe was a neighborhood staple on the Upper West Side, known for its cozy, old-fashioned vibe and excellent service. It offered a large menu with standout items like savory pasta, rich espresso, and homemade desserts. Unfortunately, the cafe has permanently closed as of April 2026, after serving the community for nearly four decades.
Limited data — scores are based on partial information and may not fully reflect this restaurant's practices.
CleanPlate Weekly
The safest gluten-free spots in NYC — a few hand-picked places in your inbox each week.
