Guanaco logo
Guanacos eat gluten-free
CleanPlate

CleanPlate Rankings

GF Pizza
in Hilton Head Island

GF FryerGF LabelsClear all
Showing 23 of 23 Restaurants — Hilton Head Island
01
The Patio Bar & Deck

Shelter Cove / Hilton Head Island

Clear gluten-free labeling, dedicated fryer, and knowledgeable staff make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners, with many positive recent experiences.

95
02
WiseGuys

North End / Hilton Head Island

Separate gluten-free menu with many steak, seafood, and risotto options; staff generally knowledgeable and several positive celiac experiences, though menu updates and consistency can vary.

93
03
Skull Creek Dockside

North End / Hilton Head Island

Extensive gluten-free menu with dedicated fryer and many positive celiac reviews; staff is knowledgeable and protocols are well-documented, though a few diners report rare issues with pasta prep.

88
04
Nala's Beach

North End / Hilton Head Island

Solid choice for gluten-free diners, with several labeled options including pizza, burgers, and fries, and recent positive reviews from gluten-free families.

84
05
SERG Takeout Kitchen

Mid-Island / Hilton Head Island

Clear gluten-free labeling and a wide range of labeled GF entrees, sides, and pizzas make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners; protocols for handling are not fully documented.

82
06
Mellow Mushroom Hilton Head Island

North End / Hilton Head Island

Certified gluten-free pizzas with clear labeling and several positive recent reviews make this a solid choice for gluten-free diners; protocols are generally well regarded, though some diners note occasional mix-ups.

80
07
Dough Boys Pizza Hilton Head

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza is available and generally well-liked, but cross-contact is a concern for celiac diners due to shared ovens and lack of dedicated protocols.

77
08
Local Pie Hilton Head

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza is available and often well-liked, but oven and prep protocols vary and cross-contact risk is inconsistently managed.

75
09
It's Greek To Me

North End / Hilton Head Island

Menu is clearly marked with gluten-free options and staff are generally knowledgeable, but diner experiences with cross-contact are inconsistent and some celiac diners have reported reactions.

74
10
Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta House Shelter Cove

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza is popular and clearly labeled, with several positive reviews, but cross-contact risk is higher due to flour-heavy kitchen and no dedicated prep area; not recommended for celiac disease.

72
11
Bella Italia Pizza

Mid-Island / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza is available and generally well-liked, but handling protocols and fryer use are inconsistent and not celiac-safe.

67
12
Frosty Frog Cafe

North End / Hilton Head Island

Several gluten-free options including pizza and wraps are available, but fried items are not safe due to a shared fryer and menu labeling is limited.

63
13
Giuseppi's Pizza

Sea Pines / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza crust is available and menu options are clearly marked, but there is no evidence of dedicated prep or equipment and diner feedback is limited.

62
14
Palmetto Market

Sea Pines / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free bread is available for breakfast and lunch sandwiches, but menu labeling and kitchen protocols are not well documented.

55
15
Big Jim's BBQ, Burgers, Pizza & Catering

Shelter Cove / Hilton Head Island

Staff can accommodate gluten-free needs with substitutions and some menu flexibility, but there is no gluten-free menu or labeling and protocols are not well documented.

55
16
Top Dawg Tavern & Pizzeria - Hilton Head

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free buns and pizza crusts are available and staff can accommodate requests, but there is no dedicated gluten-free menu or fryer and handling protocols are not well documented.

55
17
Club Seats Grille

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza crust is available and menu flexibility is possible, but gluten-free protocols and cross-contact handling are not well documented.

55
18
Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs

Coligny / Hilton Head Island

Cauliflower crust pizza is available and receives positive mentions, but gluten-free protocols and staff knowledge are not well documented.

55
19
The Bank

North End / Hilton Head Island

Several gluten-free options like pizza, burgers, and tacos are available, and staff are generally knowledgeable, but lack of clear menu labeling and no dedicated fryer or oven create inconsistent experiences for sensitive diners.

49
20
Mangiamo's Hilton Head Pizza Co

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free crust is available and staff can accommodate requests, but reviews note a shared oven and some inconsistent handling.

48
21
New York City Pizza

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza crust is available on request, but menu labeling is unclear and gluten-free handling protocols are not well documented.

45
22
Flatbread Grill & Bar Hilton Head

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free pizza crust is available, but staff knowledge and protocols are inconsistent and cross-contact risk is high.

38
23
The Lobster Bar

North End / Hilton Head Island

Gluten-free protocols and options are not documented; menu does not indicate gluten-free labeling and no reviews mention gluten-free experiences.

37